As part of a Welsh Government-supported initiative to help Welsh fisheries businesses overcome barriers to growth, 12 fishermen headed to London in November to see, fillet and taste the best fish that London has to offer, reports Katherine Weir.
The newly-formed ‘Welsh Seafood Cluster’ included fishermen and fishmongers from across Wales, who arrived in London for a tour of Billingsgate Market, dinner at the Fish Kitchen in Borough Market and visits to the fish departments of two of the most famous stores in the world – Selfridges and Harrods.
Fishing News joined the group for the morning as delegates explored Billingsgate fish market and attended a fish-filleting workshop with the Billingsgate Seafood Training School.
After some strong coffee, the Cluster met at Billingsgate market at 5am as the stalls were at their busiest. The legendary food hall – established in 1850 – was filled with elaborate produce displays from across the globe. Chris Leftwich, Chief Inspector of the Fishmonger’s Company and the market tour-guide for the group, explained that up to 140-150 varieties of fish and shellfish went on sale every day at Billingsgate and that Asian, African and West Indian customers were the big buyers here.
He said: “Billingsgate fish market has become a global seafood commodity. Buyers come to the market because of the expansive range it offers, satisfying the eclectic tastes of London.”
Taking the group from stall to stall, Chris Leftwich gave some history about the market, along with some industry insight. He was also helpful in identifying some of the fish on display – including a very odd-looking smoked barracuda – and was very honest about the quality of some of the fish that were being sold.
Group member Mandy Walters, who owns Cardigan Bay Fish with her husband Len, said: “I was surprised at the poor quality of many of the fish at Billingsgate. There was hardly anything from the UK, and I thought that was a shame. Although, you could get everything there – the choice was very good.
“Len and I have been to Brixham and Looe fish markets, where you’re seeing produce that has come straight off the boats. It’s local, as fresh as it can be and well cared-for. At Billingsgate, it was clear to see that the seafood, live and otherwise, didn’t have that same care and attention given to it on some of the stalls. Some had crabs thrown haphazardly on top of one another, and prawns were shoveled into bags for buyers. It really highlighted the difference in care at each stage from sea to plate. When we catch prawns, we are so delicate with them.”
Welsh fishmonger, Wayne Jones from Mermaid Seafoods, said: “At Billingsgate, there was a lot more exotic fish than native. It was a little disappointing to see so little in the way of UK fish in one of the UK’s biggest fish markets. Some of the stalls had excellent quality fish that I could see myself buying, but there were just as many that had poor quality on show.”
When the question of sustainable fish came up from the group, Chris Leftwich explained the current ratio at Billingsgate. “Aquaculture makes up about 50% of what is sold here, and I see this number rising each year,” he said. “Many of the countries that provide fish for the stalls find it easier and cheaper farm their fish, and the quality is getting better and better. We once did an experiment with chefs from the Savoy group, which runs Michelin-starred restaurants, to come for a tastetest of wild and farmed salmon. It was interesting to see that almost all of the chefs could not tell the difference whatsoever. It just shows how good farmed salmon tastes now.”
Carp is the number one farmed fish coming in to the market, with tilapia coming a close second. Salmon is the most popular fish across the market stalls, with bass coming next, but these food halls are now better-known for exotic species such as snappers, croakers, ribbon fish, garfish, big groupers and, the aforementioned, barracuda.
Getting the chance to speak with merchants gave those in the tour the opportunity to make new business contacts, hoping to create a Welsh supply-chain within the market. Several members of the group exchanged business cards and opened up dialogues that could lead to new business relationships.
As the market was drawing to a close, the group headed for a breakfast of mackerel kedgeree and a cup of tea, before putting their white coats and aprons on for the fish-filleting workshop with ex block-man and merchant, Ron Peachman. Held in the Billingsgate Seafood Training School, the group had everything at their disposal to learn some tricks of the trade.
Chris Leftwich, who helped to start the training school in 2000, told the group about the school’s aims at Billingsgate. “The seafood training school was set up to offer courses to all those who want to overcome their fear of the natural product of fish,” he said. “We run courses for the general public so they can feel more confident working with fish, as well as fishmonger-training and working with schools. Any profit goes towards our schools project, that teaches primary school children about the benefits of seafood consumption. This is especially import as the average age of fish consumers is currently 45.”
Ron Peachman started the workshop by showing the group how to skin a skate and the best way to cut it. He then moved on to mackerel and then to properly dressing a crab – each time, giving the group a chance to test their knife skills. Although some of the group were already dab hands at filleting, many of the fishermen were trying this for the first time.
Berwyn Dennis, of Pembrokeshire-based Albatross fisheries, said: “I really enjoyed the fish-filleting workshop and thought it was a great experience. I have caught crabs for years but it was great to get to see the other side of it when dressing our own crabs.”
The star of the filleting workshop had to be how to fillet a bass into a canoe shape. The group enjoyed tackling this one under the guidance of Ron, and Mandy Walters said she would definitely use this method to display fish at the local produce markets she goes to on a weekly basis in Cardigan Bay.
“As a fishmonger, the fishfilleting workshop was not as useful as it would have been to others but I thought Ron was an excellent teacher and the set-up at Billingsgate Seafood School was very good,” said Wayne Jones. “I thought that the work they do with educating children about fish and healthy eating is excellent.”
Harrods and Selfridges
The remainder of the fact-finding tour included a trip to Selfridges to see its fish department and speak with counter staff, and a visit to the food halls of Harrods, ending with a night out at the Fish Kitchen at Borough Market for a bit of London atmosphere.
“I found Selfridges very poor,” said Berwyn Dennis. “There were lots of fish on display but some of them were labelled incorrectly. As the manager spoke to us about the food hall, he mentioned that the bass they had was rod-and-line caught. There were several bass fishermen in our group, including myself, and it was plain to see that the fish was net-caught by the markings on them. We weren’t shy in letting him know about it either!
“Harrods, I thought, was better quality and looked fresher. They also had net-caught bass but had not labeled it as anything other than bass.”
The overall consensus from the Cluster was that Selfridges had a lot of nice, native produce on display and offered a lot for buyers, whereas the Harrods fish counter was a smaller display but was very well put together and with no misleading signage.
Overall, the group greatly enjoyed the three-day tour and saw it as educational and eye-opening, as well as creating connections for future business opportunities. There are plans scheduled for 2016 for more peer-to-peer knowledge exchange and events for those taking part in the Welsh Seafood Cluster, with every intention of coming back to Billingsgate next year.
Welsh Seafood Cluster
The Welsh Seafood Cluster will create a platform for joint action to identify and solve common problems. It aims to bring together a range of fishermen, fishmongers and aquaculture businesses, which have high-quality products and the ambition to grow alongside commercial, government and academic partners. The cluster is dedicated to adding value to fish and shellfish caught or farmed on Welsh shores.
Future Cluster activities will include:
- Peer-to-peer knowledge exchange
- Events and workshops
- Cooperation in commercial activities
- Sharing costs/resources
- Private sector businesses driving the research agenda
- Understanding and entering new markets
- Access to world-leading research
- Piloting new service provision based on business needs identified
Speaking about the Seafood Cluster, Len Walters, of Cardigan Bay Fish, said: “I think the Welsh Seafood Cluster is a great idea, and if done right it can only be a plus for us. The infrastructure in Wales is quite limited so anything that gets people working together is a good idea, especially with little companies. There’s already a good sense of community in Wales among fishermen. If there’s a change in weather and I can’t get out, then I’ll help out another fisherman who is based in a better position. Then vice-versa when the weather isn’t too good for them.”
To find out more about the Welsh Seafood Cluster, for North Wales please contact Caroline Dawson at: firstname.lastname@example.org and for South Wales contact Lowri Edwards via: email@example.com
Read the latest from Fishing News here…